Untitled Document
Komisi untuk Orang Hilang dan Korban
Tindak Kekerasan
Untitled Document Pencarian detail

IND | ENG
Untitled Document
Untitled Document
   
OPINI
Problems rife in Indonesia's police

Sumber: UPIASIA.COM | Tgl terbit: Selasa, 02 Maret 2010
Jakarta, Indonesia — The successes of Indonesia's police were the highlight of public interest over the past year. The police were credited with stripping terrorist groups of their powers and hunting down key terrorists, including the country's most wanted terrorist, Noordin M. Top, the alleged mastermind behind terrorist actions in Indonesia in the past nine years.

But the widely praised and successful war on terrorism suddenly lost significance in the public eye as a new national controversy appeared. The Corruption Eradication Commission, or the KPK, filed a corruption case against the police after two of its commissioners were arrested. The case came to be called "the gecko versus the crocodile," referring to the relative power of the commission and the police.

The case caused a huge loss of public confidence in the police, especially the controversial testimony of a high-ranking police officer, which challenged the credibility of the police as an institution.

Actually, the real issues that shame the police as an institution are not the ones seen in media reports. They are the practice of violence and the abuse of authority. Cases of police torture, arbitrary detention, denial of civil liberty and excessive use of force, which sometimes results in death, are all documented by human rights organizations.

The police are public servants meant to protect social and public order. As an institution, the police are a de jure and de facto part of public life.

The police are in a paradoxical position, however. Their role as protectors of human rights and public security gives them the privilege of using their authority, in the context of law enforcement, to deal with criminal complaints. This includes the right to use violent means.

On the other hand, improper or excessive use of violent methods can result in human rights violations. The remedial process is vulnerable to the bias of the institution’s interests, and regulated according to its relative degree of accountability and independence.

Various international human rights instruments have addressed this paradox by adopting rules and principles to govern the use of violence by police, including a proportional principle, urgent need, legal validity and accountability.

In the Indonesian context, there is an absence of effective remedies, corrective mechanisms and accountability in providing justice, especially to victims of human rights violations.

Indonesia has ratified several international human rights instruments that require it to fulfill certain obligations. These were expected to bring about better police accountability, either through internal reform or by establishing an external and independent body to supervise the police. But that does not seem to have happened.

Three aspects of security sector reform that Indonesia needs to consider include democratic oversight, rule of law and human rights.

It is important for the police to restore internal accountability. There must be clear and measurable sanctions against human rights violations to ensure that impunity is minimized or eliminated.

Effective internal affairs divisions are important in raising the level of trust among citizens. Bureaucracy should not be able to block the effectiveness of these divisions. The police force should also open itself to complaints regarding misuse of power as well as incidents of violence by its members at the lowest levels.

Furthermore, the National Police Commission must have the mandate to conduct investigations into cases of human rights violations by the police.

A recent report by Amnesty International on the issue says there are no effective external oversight mechanisms or internal accountability in the Indonesian police force regarding abuses of power. However, both the government and non-governmental organizations have undertaken several initiatives to enhance accountability in the police force.

(Papang Hidayat heads the Research and Development Bureau of the Commission for Disappeared and Victims of Violence, KontraS, in Jakarta, Indonesia. He holds a Masters degree in Arts from the University of Essex, United Kingdom. KontraS provides legal defense for victims of human rights violations and deals with issues related to transitional justice and security sector reforms.)



Isu terkait:


Wilayah terkait:


Aktor Pelaku terkait:

Dilihat : 1,429 kali

Untitled Document
ARTIKEL TERPOPULER

Dua Tahun Pemerintahan Widodo-Kalla: Minim Prestasi, Gemar Klaim Sepihak Keberhasilan Penegakan Hukum Dan HAM
Hilangnya Wiji Thukul
Penembakan dan Pembunuhan Sewenang – Wenang di Enarotali, Paniai;
Segera Bentuk Tim Independen, Pulihkan Korban dan Masyarakat;

Peringatan Hari HAM Sedunia 10 Desember 2014
HAM hari ini: Siapa yang akan bertanggung jawab?

Surat Terbuka :
"Mendesak Komnas HAM untuk Membentuk Tim Penyelidikan Terkait Dugaan Peristiwa Kejahatan Terhadap Kemanusiaan di Paniai"

Komnas HAM Harus Segera Keluarkan Rekomendasi Hasil Penyelidikan Kasus Pelanggaran HAM Berat Aceh
Pemerintah Indonesia Tidak Pro HAM dan Demokrasi Dengan Kembali Abstain dalam Resolusi PBB Terhadap Korea Utara
Bentrokan TNI Vs Polri: Ancaman Atas Rasa Aman Bagi Masyarakat
Peringatan 66 Tahun Hari HAM Internasional :
Hentikan Penyiksaan dan Penuhi Hak-Hak Korban

Komnas HAM dan Kejaksaan Agung harus Segera Panggil AM. Hendropriyono
Pembebasan Pollycarpus: Negara tidak berdaya terhadap pelaku kejahatan kemanusian
Surat Terbuka: Desakan kepada Panglima TNI untuk menindak tegas anggota TNI pelaku penyerbuan terhadap petugas Satpam Kramat Jati
Menanggapi pro dan kontra Pengakuan Prabowo Subianto atas keterlibatannya dalam kasus penculikan aktivis 1997-1998
Proses Penyelesaian Kasus Penculikan dan Pelanggaran HAM
Mempertanyakan Komitmen Indonesia sebagai Anggota Dewan HAM PBB Periode 2015 – 2018
Surat Terbuka: Desakan kepada Kapolri untuk mengusut Tuntas Praktik Mafia Perdagangan Orang di institusi Polda NTT
Pernyataan Sikap Bersama 16 Tahun Tragedy Semanggi I Presiden, Pilihlah Jaksa Agung Bermental Baja
Hentikan Perampasan Tanah, Intimidasi, Kekerasan dan Kriminalisasi Terhadap Petani Takalar, Sulawesi Selatan
Kedatangan dan Tuntutan Keluarga Tengku Bantaqiyah
Laporan Lanjutan Kerusuhan Sambas
15 tahun Tragedi Semanggi I : Mereka Lupa, Kami Luka
Potret Penanganan Kasus Pelanggaran HAM di Papua Komnas HAM Gagal Menghadirkan Keadilan
Surat : Penolakan Pemberian Gelar Pahlawan Bagi (alm.) Soeharto
Presiden Jokowi; Pilih Jaksa Agung yang Berani Melakukan Penyidikan Kasus Pelanggaran HAM Berat
POLEMIK PENYELESAIAN KASUS PELANGGARAN HAM
English
Media Sosial |        
KABAR TERKINI
Untitled Document
SIARAN PERS
BERITA
OPINI
DATA
KEGIATAN
KAMPANYE
Untitled Document

Copyright © 2015 | www.kontras.org
JL. Kramat II No. 7, Kwitang, Senen | Jakarta Pusat 10420
Tlp: 021-3919097, 3919098 | Fax: 021-3919099 | Email: kontras_98@kontras.org | Webmaster: pemelihara@kontras.org